This article is published in Aviation Week & Space Technology and is free to read until Dec 20, 2026. If you want to read more articles from this publication, please click the link to subscribe.

Opinion: Paper Compliance Won’t Cut It For SMS Mandates

READY SAFE GO sign

Independent MROs might struggle to prepare for the FAA’s upcoming 2027 SMS requirement.

Credit: Lindsay Bjerregaard/Aviation Week

For decades, aviation maintenance has relied on a simple rule: Follow the manual strictly. But as modern aircraft become more complex, a purely reactive approach is no longer enough.

Because the U.S. is a contracting state with the International Civil Aviation Organization, complying with Annex 19 is not just an option—it is an international obligation. As a result, safety management systems (SMS) are becoming the law of the land.

We already have seen this evolution in the U.S. commercial sector. Major Part 121 carriers have operated under SMS mandates for years, and progressive operators like Atlas Air have voluntarily pushed these safety frameworks well beyond the minimum requirements. Now it is the maintenance sector’s turn.

The FAA’s final SMS rule, published in April 2024, set clear deadlines for many operators. However, for independent MROs, the real wake-up call is coming from overseas. Under the U.S.-European Union Aviation Safety Agreement, FAA Part 145 repair stations that hold or need European Union Aviation Safety Agency approvals faced a hard deadline of Dec. 31, 2025. Passing the initial regulatory audit was only the first step. Today, many of these MROs are still struggling to operate their systems beyond the manual, proving that implementing a living SMS is an ongoing challenge rather than a one-time event.

Having transitioned from the hangar floor to management, I know how daunting this is for MROs that have never operated in an SMS environment. During my time at a commercial airline, I helped build an SMS from scratch. In our rush to comply, our first instinct was just to get the framework done quickly. We soon hit a wall. Adjusting existing audits, fixing safety data and actually changing the culture took a massive amount of time and painful trial and error. The biggest lesson I learned was simple: An SMS fails without the unrelenting, daily commitment of top leadership.

This upcoming mandate is going to expose a harsh reality gap in our industry. Top-tier MROs and major airlines have the money and the people to make SMS work. But smaller, independent MROs are already fighting chronic mechanic shortages. Expecting them to hire safety experts and build advanced training programs quickly is a huge ask.

Because of this pressure, I fear many MROs already have fallen into the “paper-compliance” trap just to meet the recent 2025 deadline, and others risk doing the same as the FAA’s broader 2027 mandate approaches for the rest of the industry. They hire a consultant, write a manual and put a “Paper SMS” binder on a manager’s shelf to satisfy the auditor.

This is dangerous. Right now, many hangars are simply throwing raw head count at their labor shortages. Mechanics might know how to follow a step in a manual but not why the system requires it. Recent high-profile ground incidents—like nose gears collapsing because a pin was placed in the wrong bore—prove that checking a regulatory box does not equal safety.

So how do independent MROs actually prepare?

First, it starts at the top. The accountable and quality managers cannot outsource this task. They need to be trained, understand safety risk management themselves and become the primary internal champions. They must personally drive this knowledge down to every mechanic on the floor.

Second, the SMS cannot be a separate department. It must be baked directly into your DNA. Hazard identification and risk mitigation must be written directly into your repair station and quality control manuals as well as your daily training programs.

During my time at GE Aviation, I loved our core slogan: “We bring them back safely.” That is the only goal that matters in our industry. But you cannot achieve that goal with raw head count. A true maintenance professional must be trained, certified, qualified and authorized. We must trust the dedication of our mechanics, but we need an active, living SMS to verify their competency every single day.

The mandate is here. It is time to take the SMS out of the binder and put it on the hangar floor.

Sanghoon (Benedick) Jang has more than 40 years of experience across major airlines, OEMs and MROs in quality assurance leadership, auditing, aircraft and engine leasing, and operationalizing SMS.