https://aviationweek.com/themes/custom/particle/dist/app-drupal/assets/awn-logo.svg
Skip to main content
  • Market Sector
    • Aerospace
    • Air Transport
    • MRO
    • Defense and Space
    • Business Aviation
  • Markets
    • Aerospace
      • Aircraft & Propulsion
      • Connected Aerospace
      • Emerging Technologies
      • Manufacturing & Supply Chain
      • Advanced Air Mobility
      • Commercial Space
      • Sustainability
    • Air Transport
      • Aircraft & Propulsion
      • Interiors & Connectivity
      • Airports & Routes
      • Airlines & Lessors
      • Safety, Ops & Regulation
      • Maintenance & Training
      • Sustainability
    • MRO
      • Aircraft & Propulsion
      • Interiors & Connectivity
      • Emerging Technologies
      • Supply Chain
      • Safety, Ops & Regulation
      • Workforce & Training
      • Sustainability
    • Defense and Space
      • Aircraft & Propulsion
      • Sensors & Electronic Warfare
      • Missile Defense & Weapons
      • Supply Chain
      • Budget, Policy & Operations
      • Space
      • Sustainability
    • Business Aviation
      • Aircraft & Propulsion
      • Interiors & Connectivity
      • Airports, FBOs & Suppliers
      • Flight Deck
      • Safety, Ops & Regulation
      • Maintenance & Training
      • Sustainability
  • Marketplace
  • Services
    • Services
      • Advertising
      • Marketing Services
      • Fleet, Data & APIs
      • Research & Consulting
      • Network and Route Planning
      • Marketplace
  • Store
    • Market Sector

      • Aerospace
      • Air Transport
      • MRO
      • Defense and Space
      • Business Aviation
    • Type View All Products
      • Intelligence Bundles
        • AWIN - Premium
        • AWIN - Aerospace and Defense
        • AWIN - Business Aviation
        • AWIN - Commercial Aviation
      • Market Briefings
        • Advanced Air Mobility Report - NEW!
        • Aerospace Daily & Defense Report
        • Aviation Daily
        • SpeedNews
        • The Weekly of Business Aviation
      • Directories
        • Air Charter Guide
        • Aviation Week Marketplace
        • Route Exchange
        • The Engine Yearbook
      • Data Services
        • AC-U-KWIK
        • Aircraft Bluebook
        • Airportdata.com
        • Airport Strategy and Marketing (ASM)
        • CAPA – Centre for Aviation
        • Fleet Discovery Civil
        • Fleet Discovery Military
        • Fleet & MRO Forecast
        • MRO Prospector
      • Publications
        • Air Transport World
        • Aviation Week & Space Technology
        • Aviation Week & Space Technology - Inside MRO
        • Business & Commercial Aviation
        • CAPA - Airline Leader
        • Routes magazine
        • ShowNews
      • Resources
        • Downloadable Reports
  • Events
    • Recent webinars
    • Events View All Events
      • MRO
        • MRO Americas
        • MRO Asia
        • MRO Australasia
        • MRO Baltics & Eastern Europe Region
        • MRO Europe
        • MRO Latin America
        • MRO Middle East
        • Military Aviation Logistics and Maintenance Symposium (MALMS)
        • Asia Aerospace Leadership Forum & MRO Asia-Pacific Awards
      • Commercial Aviation/A&D
        • A&D Mergers and Acquisitions
        • A&D Programs
        • A&D Manufacturing
        • A&D Raw Materials
        • A&D SupplyChain
        • A&D SupplyChain Europe
        • Advanced Air Mobility
        • Aero-Engines Americas
        • Aero-Engines Europe
        • Aero-Engines Asia-Pacific
        • Aerospace IT
        • Engine Leasing Trading & Finance Europe
        • Engine Leasing, Trading & Finance Americas
      • Air Transport
        • CAPA Live
        • Routes Americas
        • Routes Europe
        • Routes World
        • ATW Airline Awards
        • CAPA Airline Leader Summit
        • CAPA Americas Aviation & LCCs Summit
        • CAPA Latin America Aviation & LCCs Summit
        • CAPA Australia Pacific Aviation Summit
        • CTC Asia Corporate Travel Summit & Sustainability Expo
        • CAPA World Aviation Outlook Summit
        • GAD Americas
        • GAD World
      • Aerospace and Defense
        • A&D Mergers and Acquisitions Conference (ADMA)
        • A&D Manufacturing Conference
        • Aerospace Raw Materials & Manufacturers Supply Chain Conference (RMC)
        • A&D Programs
      • Awards
        • Aviation Week 20 Twenties
        • Aviation Week Laureate Awards
        • Program Excellence Awards and Banquet
        • CAPA Asia Aviation Summit & Awards for Excellence
  • About
    • About Aviation Week Network
      • Our Story
      • Content and Data Team
      • Aviation Week & Space Technology 100-Year
    • Contact Us
      • Subscriber Services
      • Advertising, Marketing Services & List Rentals
      • Content Sales
      • Events
      • PR & Communications
      • Content Licensing and Reprints
      • FAQ
  • Log In
  • Register
  • My Account
    • Profile
    • Sign Out
  • AWIN Access
  • My cart
    Back to
  1. Defense and Space

Share

Who Has The Edge In The U.S. Air Force T-X Trainer Competition?

September 13, 2016

A T-X Primer

U.S. Air Force

In the latest version of the T-X draft request for proposals (RFP), the Air Force threw contractors a curveball—incentivizing industry to exceed the threshold requirements for specific performance aspects. For the aircraft’s crucial G-capability requirement, this means that for every 0.1g above the 6.5g threshold, and up to the 7.5g objective, the bidder will receive a bonus. In other words, for two T-X proposals at the same price, the one with the higher sustained-G capability will be rated higher overall. Depending on the cost of the competing solutions, a proposal with a slightly higher price tag for a greater sustained-G capability could receive the better rating.

The Air Force will release a final RFP in December, and anticipates awarding a contract in 2017. T-X initial operational capability is planned for 2024.

Lockheed Martin /KAI T-50A

Lockheed Martin

Lockheed Martin and Korea Aerospace Industries’ (KAI) T-50A is a variant of KAI’s T-50, currently in use with the South Korean, Indonesian and Philippine air forces and recently ordered by Iraq and Thailand. Codeveloped with Lockheed’s Skunk Works, the T-50A will be built in Greenville, South Carolina.

T-50A Advantages

Lockheed Martin

> Proven design. The T-50A is an upgrade to an existing design, which reduces cost and risk. Lockheed will promote the T-50A as the “lowest-risk, lowest-cost solution that gets us most of the way,” says an industry analyst.

> Part of a family. Lockheed’s T-50 would transition easily to the Air Force’s fleet of other Lockheed aircraft—the F-35 and F-22.

> Company record. Builds on Lockheed’s history with advanced training and simulation products.

> Meets the need. T-50A’s F404-GE single engine can meet and exceed the T-X sustained G-force requirements.

T-50A Disadvantages

Lockheed Martin

> Limited flexibility.  The T-50 may struggle, particularly as the requirements change. Competitors may have more flexibility to meet the terms of the solicitation if they are developing a new aircraft rather than modifying an existing one. That limitation may be exacerbated if the Air Force continues to incentivize performance.

> Lacks backup power. The single-engine T-50 has no propulsion redundancy, which could be a safety concern for inexperienced pilots.

Raytheon/Leonardo T-100

Raytheon

The T-100 is based on Leonardo’s (formerly Finmeccanica) two-seat M-346
currently operated by the Israeli, Italian and Singaporean air forces, and
the first delivery to Poland is expected by the end of the year. Raytheon is the prime contractor, while Leonardo provides the airframe; CAE designs and
manufactures the simulation equipment, training systems and courseware; and Honeywell Aerospace provides the propulsion system. Raytheon has said the T-100 will be assembled in the U.S. but has not announced a location.

T-100 Advantages

U.S. Air Force

> Proven design. The T-100 is likely lower-cost and lower-risk than its
clean-sheet competitors.

> Company record. Raytheon and Leonardo bring significant experience
in training and simulation systems. U.S. airmen learning to fly tankers and airlifters have trained on Raytheon’s T-1A aircraft since 1993.

> Technology upgrade. Leonardo says the T-100 is the only proposal with a
virtual embedded training capability—live, virtual, and constructive (LVC)—
that enables pilots in the air to train jointly with their colleagues in simulators on the ground—a huge plus, given the U.S. Air Force’s shortfall of airframes on which to train. Pilots in Israel and Italy are already training with the new LVC system.

T-100 Disadvantages

Raytheon

> Little wiggle room. While Raytheon says the T-100 “easily meets and exceeds” the T-X minimum-G, instantaneous-turn and sustained turn-rate requirements, Leonardo chief test pilot Enrico Scarabotto told Aviation Week last year that the aircraft’s performance is “on the line.” The most recent draft RFP will likely drive up the already high standard for T-X performance, which could be a  disadvantage for the T-100.

> Less power. Raytheon touts the T-100’s twin F124 turbofan engines, provided by Honeywell Aerospace, as a safety advantage. But the F124 is not as powerful as GE’s F404. 

Wild Cards: Boeing/Saab

Boeing

Official Unveiling
​Boeing will officially reveal its clean-sheet design for the T-X competition at a Sept. 13 ceremony in St. Louis. The company did give the public a sneak peek in August, launching a promotional website containing new teaser images of the aircraft. Those artist renderings and associated videos reveal a should-mounted, shallow-anhedral wing configuration with a fuselage-mounted landing gear. The wing and tail platforms are similar to those of the T-38, and the aircraft has a flat-bottomed, rounded nose section with box-like pitot inlets on either side of the fuselage.

Black Diamond
While not much is known about Boeing’s T-X offering, the company believes a closely held manufacturing tech­nology initiative, code-named Black Diamond, will give it the competitive edge—though this did not help it much in the Long-Range Strike Bomber competi­tion, which went to Northrop Grumman. Black Diamond, led by Boeing’s Phantom Works, aims to reduce the cost of future aircraft programs by infusing more automated assembly into complex aircraft structures. Lowering manu­facturing costs while maintaining the flexibility to build a high-performance aircraft could put Boeing ahead in the T-X competition.

The Industrial Base Question
Another argument in Boeing’s favor is balancing the industrial base, although it is unclear how much weight that holds in the T-X contest. Lockheed has the F-35 and Northrop has the Long-Range Strike Bomber; without a new military aircraft program, Boeing’s St. Louis  factory may close. Given the importance of the T-X contract to Boeing’s military aircraft business, the company will likely pull out all the stops in making its bid.

The Scorpion Question

Textron Airland

Textron Airland had floated the possibility of offering a derivative of its twin-engine Scorpion jet, but it looks increasingly as if the surveillance and strike
platform will not meet the Air Force’s stringent performance requirements. Still,
a Textron spokeswoman says the company is waiting to see the service’s formal
requirements and time line before making a final decision.

Previous
Next

As the U.S. Air Force begins to bring the Lockheed Martin F-35 online, the service is looking for a new fleet of aircraft to train the next generation of pilots. Four industry teams are vying to win the contract to build 350 T-X aircraft and associated training systems—an opportunity lucrative in itself, but one that will also provide the winning team an inside track to any number of international customers who buy the F-35.

Related Content

Boeing’s Next-Generation T-X Trainer

Follow us on

Markets

  • Aerospace
  • Air Transport
  • MRO
  • Defense and Space
  • Business Aviation

Products

  • AWIN Intelligence Bundles
  • Market Briefings
  • Publications
  • Data Services
  • Directories
  • Resources

Contact Us

  • Subscriber Services
  • Advertising, Marketing Services & List Rentals
  • Content Sales
  • Events
  • PR & Communications
  • Content Licensing and Reprints
  • FAQ

Other Resources

  • Aviation Week Marketplace
  • Knowledge Center
  • Newsletters
  • ShowNews
  • Advertising - Media Kits
Copyright © 2023. All rights reserved. Informa Markets, a trading division of Informa PLC.
  • Accessibility
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Terms of Use