SpaceX: Engine Anomaly Overview


Posting this as background to our June 17 story in AW&ST:

In a Feb. 14 briefing to congressional oversight committees, SpaceX explained what went wrong with the Oct. 8, 2012 Falcon 9 launch that successfully delivered a Dragon cargo vessel to the ISS, but which left a secondary payload launched for Orbcomm in the wrong obit. Note that SpaceX has since launched a Falcon 9 mission that ultimately sent Dragon to the space station in March. In addition, the company is expected to debut a new, more powerful version of the Falcon 9 Merlin 1C engine - the Merlin 1D -- this year.

Engine Anomaly Overview

An exhaustive review of all available data by both SpaceX and NASA suggests the engine anomaly experienced on CRS-1 was likely the result of an undetected material flaw in the engine chamber jacket.

The material flaw was most likely introduced during engine production. For Merlin 1C, the engine chamber jacket is formed by an electroplating process, and this particular chamber required extra plating cycles during production. This re-plating process is not uncommon, but does have the potential to introduce flaws in the jacket that can be difficult to detect.   

In addition, during testing, the main combustion chamber on this engine experienced a unique combination of environments as compared to the other engines. While none of these observations exceeded demonstrated qualification margins, the combination of these environments likely exacerbated the material flaw on  the engine’s main combustion chamber jacket.

During flight, the data suggests this material flaw ultimately developed into a breach in the main combustion chamber. This breach released a jet of hot gas and fuel in the direction of the main fuel line causing a secondary leak and ultimately a rapid drop in engine pressure. As a result, the flight computer commanded shutdown of engine 1 and Falcon 9 continued on its path to ensure Dragon’s entry into orbit for subsequent rendezvous and berthing with the ISS.

These findings correspond with what was observed by long range tracking cameras during the launch. The video shows the nacelle panels that enclosed engine 1 as well as adjacent panels  being jettisoned from the engine section of the first stage.  These panels are designed to relieve pressure if necessary, as would be in the event of an engine chamber breach.

Falcon 9 did exactly what it was designed to do. Like the Saturn V (which experienced engine loss on two flights) and modern airliners, Falcon 9 is designed to handle an engine out situation and still complete its mission. No other rocket currently flying has this ability.

For the upcoming CRS-2 flight, SpaceX reviewed samples with known defects to supplement existing inspection techniques and re-inspected the CRS 2 engine chambers for possible issues. No critical flaws were discovered. In addition, the engines for CRS 2 have not seen as strenuous environments than the engines flown on the CRS 1.

Please or Register to post comments.

What's On Space?

On Space

From The Archives

Aviation Week is approaching its 100th anniversary in 2016. In a series of blogs, our editors highlight editorial content from the magazine's long and rich history.


Aug 27, 2015

Aviation Week Lifts Veil On Boeing B-52 Bomber (1952) 16

In 1952, Aviation Week provided the first details on the new Boeing B-52 bomber....More
Aug 14, 2015

Bonanza Travel Pays 3

The legendary Beechcraft Bonanza has an impressive production record, so perhaps the marketers back in 1949 were onto something when they coined the phrase "Bonanza travel pays."...More
Aug 14, 2015

Venerable Boeing 727 Prototype To Fly Again 29

The most famous 727, the prototype aircraft which would join United as N7001U, was delivered to the airline in October 1964 having served its time as a Boeing test aircraft....More
Aug 13, 2015

Aviation Week And The Bomb

Aviation News did not predict how nuclear weapons would change the world. But neither did anyone else....More
Aug 13, 2015

Collins Radar Takes The Ups And Downs Out Of Flying

Turbulence? Rockwell Collins had a solution for those bumpy rides in the early 80s with its WXR-700 Doppler Weather Radar....More
Blog Archive
Penton Corporate

Sponsored Introduction Continue on to (or wait seconds) ×