Directive Targets 'Relic' 737NG Autothrottle Issue Spotlighted In Turkish Crash

FAA on Monday will publish a proposed AD targeting the Boeing 737NG flight altimeter/autothrottle interface anomaly that Dutch investigators concluded was a huge link in the chain of events that caused the February 2009 crash of Turkish Airlines Flight 1951 near Amsterdam Schiphol Airport.
Here's how the report lays out the issue:

The Boeing 737-800 can be flown either manually or automatically. This also applies to the management of the engines. The autothrottle regulates the thrust of the engines. The aircraft is fitted with two radio altimeter systems, one on the left and one on the right. In principle, the autothrottle uses the altitude measurements provided by the left radio altimeter system. Only if there is an error in the left system that is recognised as such by the system, the autothrottle will use the right-hand radio altimeter system.

In a worst-case scenario, the left-side altimeter tells the autothrottle that the aircraft is lower than it is while the right-side autopilot is flying the plane, but the left altimeter thinks its data is good. Fly low enough in this condition, such as a final approach, and data from the left altimeter can roll the throttles back to idle while the right-side autopilot, relying on accurate data from its altimeter, will keep pushing the nose up to maintain the glideslope.
If this happens at too low an altitude and the pilots aren't quick enough to recover from an unexpected aircraft state, the results can be devastating. 
This is what happened to Turkish Flight 1951. Not for nothing, the flight's crew included a captain acting as a flight instructor alongside the less experienced first officer, as well as a "safety pilot" who, among other things, was supposed to help the captain--tasked with a few extra instructional duties--keep an eye on the aircraft state.
The three pilots, one crewmember, and five passengers died in the accident.

blog post photo
Photo: Dutch Safety Board
Again, from the report:

This [design] a relic from the Boeing 737, certificated long ago, which in the original design prioritised the provision of information to the left pilot (captain). This original design has now been superseded by both technical facilities and a democratisation and reallocation of pilot duties in the cockpit. It is noticeable that this subject cannot be found in any of the Boeing 737 manuals or training documents for pilots. Pilots therefore do not have the correct knowledge about links between the control systems and data input for their own aircraft. The result of this is an incomplete or even incorrect ‘mental model’ of the automated flight control.

FAA's AD is based on Boeing service bulletin issued in November. The directive will require autothrottle computer replacements or modifications on affected 737NGs, which FAA says number 497 in the U.S. alone.
"The service bulletin referenced in the NPRM is one of the final components of the changes Boeing has made," a Boeing spokesman notes. 
Others include operations manual updates and software changes in April 2010, and a July 2010 production line cut-in that added an AIRSPEED LOW aural alert to new 737NGs.

Please or Register to post comments.

What's Things With Wings?

Aviation Week's civil aviation blog

Blog Archive

Sponsored Introduction Continue on to (or wait seconds) ×