The Challenge of Nine


Congratulations go to SpaceX for a successful unmanned freight delivery to an orbiting space station, a capability that the Soviets/Russians have possessed since 1978, and which has also been successfully demonstrated by both the Japanese and European space agencies over the past few years.

What makes this genuinely significant is that SpaceX has a viable strategy for lowering launch costs enough to be able to capture a significant fraction of the commercial launch market away from United Launch Alliance, Arianespace, Russia and China, provided that future customers can tolerate major launch schedule delays, and China does not employ the same dumping tactics that put Solyndra into receivership.

Only time will tell how reliable the more complex Falcon 9 rocket will prove to be, compared to simpler designs from established competitors. Taking into account catastrophic failure modes, the bad news is that each rocket motor will need to be nine times more reliable than a single motor design. The good news is that with each launch SpaceX will be in a position to climb the operational learning curve nine times faster than a single motor design.

We wish all of them the very best of luck, although thus far the long delays suggest that this recent success has been more the result of preparation rather than chance.

Space is a very unforgiving environment.

Please or Register to post comments.

What's On Space?

On Space

From The Archives

Aviation Week is approaching its 100th anniversary in 2016. In a series of blogs, our editors highlight editorial content from the magazine's long and rich history.


Jan 31, 2016

Tupolev 104: Harsh Proof Of Rapid Soviet Progress (1956) 18

Since little detail was available of the Russian design and built Tupolev 104, a profile was compiled for Aviation Week, based entirely on observations from photographs, experts such as engineers knowledgeable in typical Russian aircraft design and of its landing at London Airport....More
Blog Archive
Penton Corporate

Sponsored Introduction Continue on to (or wait seconds) ×